Buying a plant
Evaluating a
plant supplier.
The useful question is not which supplier is best. It is which claims in front of you can be verified, and what the contract says when one of them turns out to be wrong.
Get help with your projectReading a claim
Four tests for any
performance statement.
A figure can be entirely true in one circumstance and useless for your project. These four questions usually establish, within a single conversation, whether a claim transfers to your material and scale.
On what material?
A yield or quality figure is a property of a feedstock and a process together, never of equipment alone.
Measured where, by whom, how long?
A laboratory rig, a short demonstration run and a plant that has operated for months are three different kinds of evidence.
Can it be seen running?
An operating plant on comparable material, visited by you, with the operator free to speak, is the strongest evidence this industry offers.
Work through the four tests in full
Test one: on what material?
Ask which material the figure was measured on, with what analysis, and how closely that matches yours. If the answer is a waste category rather than an analysis, the figure does not transfer to your project.
Test two: measured where, by whom, over how long?
Ask explicitly which kind of evidence you are being shown, whether anyone independent witnessed the measurement, and over what period it was sustained. Each kind is useful; they are simply not interchangeable.
Test three: is it guaranteed, and against what remedy?
The practical status of a figure is defined by the contract. Is it an estimate, a target, or a guarantee with a defined test procedure and a defined consequence for failing it? Where a supplier is confident in a number they will generally put it in the contract with a remedy attached; where they prefer not to, you have learned how firm the number is, which is useful either way.
Test four: can it be seen running?
If no plant exists processing comparable material, that is important information rather than a disqualification. It means you are funding a first-of-a-kind installation, and it should be priced and structured accordingly.
Three things to establish early
- Technology owner or reseller?
- Establish who owns the process intellectual property, who designed the plant, who manufactures it and who stands behind the warranty. These are often four different parties, and it determines who you can hold responsible.
- Which legal entity contracts?
- Confirm the entity in the relevant companies register, and who signs. Brand presentation and contracting entity are not always the same, and the entity is what a court would consider.
- What does a certificate actually cover?
- Pressure equipment, machinery and electrical compliance marks certify conformity with defined standards. They are not statements that a process will achieve a commercial yield.
Diligence
Seven things to ask for,
and why each matters.
Most of what decides your business case is not in the documents you have already been given. It is in reference plants, test work on your own material and the engineering depth behind the quotation.
Reference list with status
Location, feedstock, capacity, start date and current operating status. Plants that were built and plants that are running both appear in reference lists.
Test work on your material
The only evidence that transfers directly to your project. Worth paying for, and retain the right to the data.
Mass and energy balance
A supplier who cannot produce one for your feedstock has not yet engineered your plant, whatever the quotation implies.
Open the verification checklist
| Area | Ask for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Operating references | Installations with location, feedstock, capacity, start date and current operating status | Separates plants that are running from plants that were built. Both appear in reference lists; only one tells you the technology works in practice |
| Site visit access | An unaccompanied conversation with the operator of a plant on comparable material | Operators will tell you about availability, maintenance burden and the problems that never reach a brochure |
| Test work on your material | Bench or pilot processing of a representative sample of your own feedstock, with the analytical results released to you | The only evidence that transfers directly to your project |
| Engineering depth | Process flow diagram, mass and energy balance, utility list, equipment list, plot layout | Shows whether your plant has actually been engineered yet, or whether a standard design is being offered against your enquiry |
| Safety basis | Evidence of a structured hazard study, the relief and inerting philosophy, and the compliance route for your jurisdiction | Hot organic vapour and flammable gas in one plant. This is the area where thin engineering is most consequential |
| Commercial standing | Audited accounts, the contracting entity, parent company guarantees where offered | A long warranty is only as good as the entity able to honour it. This is a separate question from whether the technology works |
| After-sales reality | Spare parts availability and lead time, service presence in your region, documentation language, training scope | Decides your availability in year three, which is when the offtake contract is being tested |
On reference visits
Go. Take an engineer who is not involved in the sale. Ask the plant operator what breaks, how often, what the restart takes, and what they would specify differently. Ask what proportion of the year the plant actually runs. The answers are rarely in any document you have been given, and they are the answers that determine your business case.
Contract
Five clauses worth
more than the brochure.
By the time you are reading drafts, the sales conversation is over and a more precise one begins. These clauses are where performance risk is actually allocated.
The performance test
What must be demonstrated, on what feedstock, for how long, measured by whom, using which methods. A guarantee without a defined test is hard to enforce.
Consequences of failure
Repeated attempts to remedy, liquidated damages, a price reduction or a right to reject — and whether the liability cap relates to the loss you would suffer.
The feedstock specification
The clause most disputes turn on. Make sure it matches your real range and worst case, not a convenient idealisation.
Read all five clauses, plus signals worth noting
The performance test
Pay particular attention to the feedstock used for the test. If it is cleaner or drier than your real supply, the test demonstrates something you will never reproduce in operation.
Consequences of failure
A cap set at a small fraction of contract value transfers the real risk to you. That may be a normal commercial position in the market, but you should price it rather than discover it.
Payment against milestones
Payment terms are a risk-allocation instrument. Large payments before anything verifiable has happened put the risk on the buyer. Retention held until the performance test passes, and staged payments tied to demonstrated progress, align the supplier’s interest with yours.
The feedstock specification
The supplier will warrant performance on feed within a specification; everything outside it becomes your problem. Include moisture and contaminants, and include the worst delivery you would have to accept.
Intellectual property and continuity
If the supplier ceases trading, can you still operate, maintain and repair the plant? Do you hold the drawings, the control system configuration and the right to have parts made? Escrow arrangements and clear licence terms matter more in a young industry than in a mature one.
Signals worth noting
None of the following proves anything on its own. Each is a reason to ask one more question, and a pattern of several is worth taking seriously.
- No operating reference on a comparable material, and no clear explanation of why
- Reluctance to run your sample, or to release the analytical results
- Yield figures with no stated feedstock analysis or test basis
- Figures offered verbally that do not survive into the draft contract
- Pressure to sign against an expiring discount
- No mass and energy balance for your feedstock
- Vagueness about which legal entity contracts and who stands behind the warranty
- A quotation with no itemised exclusions
Signals in the other direction
Written exclusions. A balance you can check. Willingness to test your material and share the results. A performance test the supplier helps you tighten. Operators who will speak freely. An engineer in the room who contradicts the salesperson on a technical point.
Where to check the requirements at source
- US OSHA: process safety management — A yardstick for the rigour to expect of a safety basis
- ASME codes and standards — Pressure equipment design codes referenced in plant specifications
- NFPA codes and standards — Fire and combustible-dust standards for feed handling and storage
- FIDIC — Standard forms of contract used for plant and design-build projects
Offered as further reading. None of these bodies is cited in support of a figure on this site, and none endorses it.
Put the research to work
Your project.
The right questions, answered.
Plant selection, supplier evaluation, feasibility and product markets. Tell us where you are and what you need to establish.