Project development
Developing the project
in the right order.
Each stage below is cheap relative to the one after it, and each exists to stop a bad project before it becomes an expensive one.
Get help with your projectStage one
Define the material,
then prove it.
Start with a written description of what will physically arrive at the gate — source, form, moisture, contaminants, variation between loads and seasons, and the worst delivery you would have to accept. Then confirm it with laboratory analysis of representative samples.
Sampling is a discipline
One sample from one load tells you about one load. Use a plan that reflects how the material actually varies, analysed by an accredited laboratory.
Ask the holder, not the market
Regional arising statistics are not supply. A delivery agreement, or a serious conversation with whoever physically controls the material, is supply.
Free feedstock rarely stays free
The moment a plant depends on a material, its holder learns it has value. A plant financed on free feedstock and operated on purchased feedstock is a predictable failure.
What this stage has to produce
In parallel with the analysis, establish the commercial reality of supply. Who controls this material today, what do they currently do with it, what does it cost, and under what term can it be contracted?
The output of this stage is a feedstock specification with a stated range, supported by analysis, plus a realistic view of contracted supply volume and price. Everything downstream depends on it, and it is the cheapest stage in the project.
Stage two
Find the buyer
before the plant.
Decide which output stream carries the project, then ask the people who would buy it what they require. The answer is a specification in properties and test methods, and it is usually more demanding than expected.
This is the stage most often skipped
Skipping it is what produces plants that run correctly and still fail.
Deal with every stream
For each output: what it is, who takes it, against what specification, at what price basis, and who pays transport.
The disposal line matters
A stream with no buyer is a recurring cost with a regulatory classification attached. Model it explicitly.
The per-stream checklist, and why standards help
A liquid that no refinery, blender or industrial user will accept is an operating cost, not a product. A solid carbon with ash content outside what a user tolerates is a disposal problem. The specification has to come from the buyer before the plant is designed, not after it is commissioned.
Where the destination is internal use — returning non-condensable gas to the heat duty, for instance — write that down too, because it has permitting consequences.
For each output stream, written down
- What it is, physically
- Who takes it
- Against what specification and test methods
- At what price basis, and who sets it
- Who pays transport, and in what packaging
- What happens to it when it is off-specification
- What the disposal route and cost would be if there is no buyer
Where a standard exists for the material you intend to sell, work to it from the beginning. Standard test methods and terminology for recovered carbon black are developed by ASTM Committee D36, and specifications exist for pyrolysis liquid fuels as well. Selling against a recognised specification is far easier than selling against your own description.
Stages three and four
Test the material.
Establish the permit path.
Bench work shows whether the chemistry behaves as expected. Pilot work on a continuous rig tests what bench work cannot: whether material feeds, whether solids discharge, whether fouling accumulates, whether quality holds over a run.
Retain the right to the data
A test campaign is a small fraction of a plant’s cost and the only evidence that genuinely belongs to your project.
Make samples for your buyers
Produce enough of each output stream to send to prospective buyers for their own assessment. Their judgement is the one that matters.
Permitting is a parallel track
It frequently governs the timeline, and the design decisions needed to satisfy it are far cheaper before equipment is ordered.
The classification questions that drive both
Establish early which authority has jurisdiction, how your incoming material is classified, how your residues are classified, which emissions limits apply, and what the application requires. In many jurisdictions the regulatory classification of the feed and of the residue is the single most consequential fact in the project, because it determines both the permit route and the operating cost of residue handling.
Engage the regulator in a pre-application discussion where that is available; it is usually free and consistently worth doing.
Jurisdictional starting points
- United States: waste classification under RCRA, air permitting under the Clean Air Act, plus state and local requirements.
- European Union: the Waste Framework Directive and the wider EU waste framework, implemented through national law.
- Cross-border movement: where feedstock or residue crosses borders, the Basel Convention regime may apply to the shipment. Check before building a supply chain that depends on it.
Stages five to seven
Fix the scope. Price it
whole. Then decide.
Write the specification yourself, build the budget from scope blocks rather than a supplier total, and arrive at the equipment decision holding tested feedstock data, buyer-confirmed product specifications and a known permit path.
Stopping is a result
The projects that damage people are the ones that could not be stopped because too much had been spent. Define in advance what would cause you to walk away at each stage.
Owner’s engineer
Technical review that is not paid by the equipment sale is inexpensive next to the capital at stake.
Know your estimate class
State the accuracy range to your board. AACE International’s recommended practices set out the conventional framework.
Why this order makes a disciplined “no” cheap
Fix the scope boundary
Cover the feedstock range, the product specifications, the site conditions, the utilities available and the emissions limits that apply. State explicitly what you require the supplier to provide and what you will provide. This document is what makes competing quotations comparable.
Price the whole plant
Build the budget from the scope blocks: feed preparation, main process, gas handling, abatement and monitoring, product storage, civils, utilities, control and safety, engineering, freight and duties, installation, commissioning, spares, training, owner’s costs and contingency. Then build the operating model alongside it, using the delivered feedstock price you established in stage one rather than the one you hoped for.
Decide, or stop
A project that does not survive honest numbers should be stopped, and stopping at this point costs a tiny fraction of stopping after construction. The purpose of running the stages in this order is to make a disciplined no cheap and available.
If the project does survive, you reach the equipment decision holding a tested feedstock specification, buyer-confirmed product specifications, a known permit path and a complete scope. That is a strong position with every supplier you talk to, and it is exactly where you want to be when the capital is committed.
Where to check the requirements at source
- US EPA: RCRA — Waste classification in the United States
- US EPA: Clean Air Act permitting — Air permitting programmes relevant to project timeline
- EU Waste Framework Directive — How feed and residue are classified in the EU
- Basel Convention — Controls on transboundary movement of waste
Offered as further reading. None of these bodies is cited in support of a figure on this site, and none endorses it.
Put the research to work
Your project.
The right questions, answered.
Plant selection, supplier evaluation, feasibility and product markets. Tell us where you are and what you need to establish.